Evil Monkey’s Guide to Kosher Imaginary Animals

(Kosher?)UPDATE: The Kosher Guide to Imaginary Animals will be published in February 2010, hopefully in time for Purim! You can preorder it here. It is a lavishly illustrated book with humorous descriptions of all of the beasts on display, with an intro by Ann, a forward by Joseph Nigg, the bestselling author of How to Raise and Train and Dragon, and a discussion about imaginary animal recipes with Food Network star Duff Goldman. It's a 5 x 7 small-sized hardcover--the perfect gift.In honor of upcoming holidays like Passover, I thought I would ask Jeff's better half, Ann VanderMeer, editor of Weird Tales , co-editor of New Weird and Steampunk, and a practicing Jew who teaches bat/bar mitzvah students, to give us an idea of which fantastical animals and beings would be kosher and which would not be kosher, in terms of gnawin' off a bit o' that. Answers below... - Evil MonkeyAbumi-Guchi (furry creatures formed from the stirrup of a mounted military commander) - Ann [with look of disbelief]: "Do they chew their prey?" EM: "I think so." A: "Then no. Besides, the provenance is suspect."Aigi Kampoi (fish-tailed goat) - A: "Yes, that would be kosher because it has cloven hoofs, chews its cud, and has fins and scales. Although, it would still be considered a meat meal, even though it's partially fish. So you can't eat dairy with it."Amikiri (snake-bird-lobster) - A: "No. Absolutely not. The snake and lobster parts make it treyf."Arkan Sonney (fairy hedgehog) - A: "No, because hedgehogs aren't kosher, so a fairy hedgehog wouldn't be any different, monkey." EM: "But they're delicious!" A: "Even so."Baku (dream-devouring tapir) - A: "That's considered a swine. It doesn't chew its cud." EM: "What if it was a dream-devouring cow? Would the dream-devouring disqualify it?" A: "No. As long as you don't consider that scavenging."Brag (malevolent water horse) - A: "Horses are not kosher, no matter how aquatic."Bugbear (bearlike goblin) - A: "Bears have paws. Things with paws are not kosher. And they eat meat." EM: "If it was a bear with hooves that chewed cud and the goblin part was just in its stomach, would it be kosher?" A: "Then it wouldn't be a bear, idiot."Chupacabra - A: "It's definitely a carnivore." EM: "What if it's just for show and they don't eat their prey?" A: "Well I'm sure they don't chew their cud and have cloven hooves unless the chupacabra turns out to be some kind of mutant cow."Cornish Owl-Man - A: "Unfortunately an owl is not kosher because it is a bird of prey--Lev. 11:17, and obviously you cannot eat a man because that is cannibalism." EM: "Again, though--delicious!"Dragon - A: "No reptiles or amphibians." EM: "No exceptions? What about if it chews its cud?" A: "Shut up."Encantado (dolphin-human shapeshifter) - EM: "Surely it's kosher when it's a dolphin." A: "A dolphin is a mammal just like you. It has no scales, even though it has fins. Besides, what if it starts changing while you're eating it?"ET - A: ".....?" EM: "It had cloven hooves." A: "It's a humanoid." EM: "It looked like a pile of dung. It seemed to chew cud. Would any alien be automatically un-kosher?" A: "I guess it really depends on the alien--like a plant?" EM: "An alien that comes down to Earth." A: "No, because they wouldn't be considered an animal." EM: "What if they looked just like a cow, but with a brain?" A: "Cows have brains." EM: "Arggh!" A: "But cows don't travel to other planets using their brains." EM: "My point exactly!" A: "Anything intelligent is not kosher."Headless Mule (fire-spewing, headless, spectral mule) - A: "No, because the mule itself, even if it weren't fire-breathing, isn't kosher. The fire doesn't cleanse it." EM: "But it's self-cooking!"Hippocamp (horse-fish) - A: "Unfortunately, the horse part makes it treyf, and a little bit of treyf makes everything treyf. So if you had 99 percent fish and one percent horse it would still be treyf." EM: "And a really fucked up looking hippocamp!"Hobbits - A: "Not kosher at all. They are sentient beings." EM: "That brings up a point. They're actually not sentient because they're not real, so aren't they just as kosher as air." Ann: "No comment."Hoopoe (rooster-swallow-chicken-snake-goose-lobster-stag-fish hybrid) - A: "The snake and the lobster make it unkosher--see Hippocamp above for percentages."Jackalope - A: "No, rabbits are not kosher." EM: "Not even rabbits?!! Why not?" A: "Because although it chews the cud, it does not have hooves."Jaud (vampirized premature baby) - A: "Oh. Do I even have to tell you?" EM: "I guess not." A: "Number one, a vampire drinks blood. Blood ingesting is a no-no. Number 2--baby?!?!"Jotai (animated folding screen cloth) - A: "Sure, why not? It's not a food item. Scarf it down to your heart's delight. So long as it's made from plant fibers, not a treyf animal. And only one type of fiber--no mixing of wool and linen." EM: "Doesn't sound too good..."Man-Eating Tree - A: "Tree part yes, man-eating no, therefore treyf."Mermaid - A: "No, for the obvious reasons." EM: "What if you marry one? Is that kosher? Will a rabbi marry you?" A: "Kosher is a term about eating, not about sex." EM: "I'm not talking about sex--I'm talking about marriage!" A: "If the mermaid is Jewish, the rabbi will probably marry you. But only if you're Jewish too. But you'll definitely have to find the right rabbi..."Mongolian Death Worm - A: "No, because you cannot eat anything that crawls on its belly." EM: "Does that mean an injured kosher animal that is crawling along isn't kosher any more?" A: "Yes, because you can't eat an animal that's been injured or is sick." EM: "It's a wonder you haven't all starved to death."Pollo Maligno (cannibalistic chicken spirit) - A: "When you say cannibalistic, do you mean a chicken that eats other chickens or a chicken that eats humans?" EM: "When I say Pollo Maligno, I have no idea what I mean except I sound fierce." A: "Well, chickens are kosher, but if it's eating meat, probably not..." EM: "POLLO MALIGNO! POLLO MALIGNO!"Pope Lick Monster - A: "I don't know what that is." EM: "I think it's a monster that licks the Pope." A: "If it's licking the Pope, it's probably treyf."Sasquatch - A: "What is sasquatch like?" EM: "I'd imagine kind of stringy." A: "No, that's not what I mean." EM: "Kind of ape-like I guess." A: "If it's still undetermined, it might be kosher, but maybe not."Sea Monkeys - A: "Only if they have fins and scales. Wait a minute--aren't they actually brine shrimp? Then no." EM: "I don't think so. The package shows these cute little things with human faces." A: "Well, in that case...NO!"Shedim (chicken-legged demon) - A: "If you have to eat a demon, you really ought to just go off and die somewhere." EM: "Good point."Vegetable Lamb of Tartary - A: "Oh, absolutely kosher! Vegetables are kosher and lambs are kosher! Nice combination. How about some mint with that meal!"EM: "And monkeys aren't kosher, right?"A: "You certainly aren't."UPDATE: If not coming here from Boing Boing, check out additional comments on their post about, er, this post.Also, want more silliness? Check out beer-book pairings with Arianna Huffington, Michael Chabon, and others.